Gerardo's Pizzeria, Mt. Kisco, NY

Nestled in the heart of Mt. Kisco, Gerardo's Pizzeria offers a vibrant taste of Italy with a warm and welcoming neighborhood vibe. This beloved pizza restaurant and Italian eatery impresses with its diverse menu, delivering everything from classic Sicilian slices to inventive specialties that satisfy even the most discerning palates.

At Gerardo's, each bite tells a story of authentic Italian tradition blended with creative flair. Their Beef Patty Pizza Slice is a crowd favorite, boasting a flavorful, juicy topping layered over a perfectly baked crust that strikes a beautiful balance between airy and crunchy. The Eggplant Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza showcase bold, robust flavor profiles: the eggplant comes with roasted peppers and fresh garlic smothered in homemade sauce, creating a harmonious medley of savory notes, while the buffalo chicken slice delivers a spicy kick with a generous portion of tender, seasoned chicken that leaves a lingering warmth on the palate.

Beyond pizza, Gerardo's enchants with an impressive selection of pasta dishes that feel lovingly homemade. The creamy richness of Penne Vodka with Grilled Chicken and the delicate freshness of Fettuccini Primavera (available with a choice of garlic oil or cream sauce) evoke comfort and refinement in every forkful. For those craving a bit of heat, the Penne Arrabiata offers a lively combination of marinara, garlic, tomatoes, and hot cherry peppers that invigorate the senses. Meanwhile, hearty plates like Gnocchi Bolognese and Spaghetti Carbonara immerse you in classic Italian indulgence, perfectly balanced by thoughtful seasoning and expertly prepared sauces.

Entrees stand out just as brightly, with iconic dishes like the Chicken Parmigiana—a golden breaded cutlet bathed in savory tomato sauce and topped with melted mozzarella—delighting diners who crave traditional Italian comfort food. The Chicken Piccata and Chicken Marsala add sophistication with their vibrant lemon-caper and aromatic mushroom-marsala wine sauces, respectively, showcasing the kitchen’s skill and passion.

The inviting atmosphere at Gerardo's Pizzeria complements its culinary offerings, blending friendly service with a clean, casual space that makes every visit feel like dining at a cherished local gem. Customers repeatedly praise not only the food’s quality but also the genuine warmth in the staff interactions. Whether you're popping in early for a breakfast slice or settling in for a cozy evening meal, Gerardo’s balances fast, attentive service with a comfortable dining experience.

One customer, Bob, shared his pleasant surprise at the light, airy Sicilian slice and the perfectly seasoned buffalo chicken, noting the owner’s friendly and helpful demeanor. Meanwhile, Meli H found the grilled chicken and broccoli to be "oh so tasty," praising the clean atmosphere and welcoming staff that invite repeat visits. Peter Nekos appreciated the “nice quality local place” feel and the unique opportunity to enjoy pizza early in the morning, while Richiefromtheyo raved about the eggplant and roasted pepper pizza’s fresh garlic and homemade sauce that create a rich, indulgent bite. Even those who had experienced previous rudeness find comfort in the new ownership’s attentive and kind approach, as Hilary Davidson attests.

Gerardo’s Pizzeria in Mt. Kisco perfectly embodies a neighborhood eatery where authentic Italian flavors are crafted with care, passion, and an inviting spirit. Whether you’re craving a slice with a satisfying crunch, a pasta dish brimming with depth, or an entree that transports you straight to Italy, Gerardo’s promises a culinary journey you’ll happily return to time and again.